Magnifico!  A Jitterbean Girl food blog
Home     Archives     Categories     Previous     Next
November 18, 2007
The UNTESTED (gasp!) Thanksgiving menu!

With, oh, about four days to spare, I'm finally sitting down to plan my Thanksgiving dinner. This may seem odd because I put way more effort into planning dinner parties, but Thanksgiving? Eh! To me, Thanksgiving is more about delicious but traditional food that is simple by necessity (I don't know about you, but preparing a huge feast with only one oven is a daunting task), whereas when I'm having people over, well, to be honest, I'm generally cooking and plating to impress.

So this year, the first without Adult Supervision, I'll present a menu comprised partially of (eek!) untested recipes, without (gasp!) photos, before the event has actually occurred! Because, really, posting a Thanksgiving menu after the fact has questionable value.

I've decided to include breakfast on this menu because in my family we always overlook it. Me, I think it's important to start the day right and some savory breakfast scones would definitely qualify in that regard. Sometime in between-ish we'll enjoy a simple cheese course. When it comes time for dinner we'll have a turkey version of The Herbed Bird (be on the lookout for an awesome soup made with the leftovers), a bread (undecided between beer rolls, Parmesan whole wheat bread, or a roll version of the delectably light whole wheat buttermilk loaves I made last Sunday), roasted shallots with thyme and butternut squash, roasted pear salad with candied walnuts and blue cheese, mashed potatoes (garlic? Will I use russets, reds, or yukon golds?) and some sort of stuffing or cranberry sauce or relish that Cory will decide upon since I'm not much of a fan of those things. We will finish, of course, with pumpkin pie. The wine will be flowing all day, and it will be a glorious celebration of, well, gluttony.

Enticed? OF COURSE YOU ARE. Let's get cookin'!

The UNTESTED first-ever adult un-supervised, wine-soaked Stacey-and-Cory Thanksgiving menu!

Serves 4-ish (but we'll be scaling most of these recipes down to serve two)

Note: Sorry this isn't up to usual QC/design/recipe standards... I just worked an 84-hour week and haven't had time to sit down and put a huge amount of time into it. I'll come through after the fact and get this spruced up.

A breakfast to be thankful for
Savory bacon and scallion breakfast scones (now with its own entry) with Bailey's cappuccinos

The requisite cheese course
A bottle of Wrongo Dongo
A wedge of Stella Asiago
Two good crisp fall apples (like Jonagold or Golden Delicious) or ripe-but-firm pears (like Bartlett or red Anjou), cored and sliced

The Herbed Big Bird
No, we won't be roasting any beloved childhood muppets. What we will be doing is making a moist, tender, and delightfully aromatic turkey.

Follow the directions for the herbed bird (chicken version) with following modifications:

Buy massive quantities of the herbs. A little two-ounce poultry herb pack is not going to cut it here.

After you've rubbed the appropriate amount of herbs under the skin, stuff the cavity of the bird with the remaining herbs and with quartered onions and any other aromatics that tickle your fancy.

Let the turkey rest for 20 minutes after taking it out of the oven before slicing into it.

We'll be drinking V. Sattui Crow Ridge Zinfandel with our dinner. Yes, a red with poultry. Me no likey whites for more than three sips.

The battle of the bread, or the rollicking rolls, if you prefer (untested)
What will I use??? Will I go with Beer Rolls, whole wheat parmesan bread, or whole-wheat buttermilk rolls (recipe not posted yet, but can be found in Laurel's Kitchen Bread Book)? Oh, the choices!!! What I do know is that oven space is going to be at a premium come Thursday. I'll post the winner here after the fact.

Roasted shallots with thyme and butternut squash
In case you didn't already know, it's a sin to exclude shallots from your Thanksgiving menu.

Roasted pear salad with candied walnuts and blue cheese

Mashed potatoes
Does anyone actually use a recipe for this? I've always thought that mashed potatoes were supposed to be an intuitive dish. I haven't decided which type of potato to use yet... it will probably depend on my mood. In my mind, mashers made with russets are classic comfort food that I grew up on and reds are more of an elegant, refined dish made to impress. They both have their place, but I'm betting that russets are the spud that will make it onto my table this Thursday.

For russets: Boil the desired number of potatoes until easily pierced with a fork. Drain and let cool slightly. Leave the skins on and mash unevenly, leaving lumps behind. Add butter and milk to taste, and cheddar cheese if so desired. Serve immediately.

For reds: Place a head of garlic in a covered casserole dish and roast in a 425 degree oven for 45 minutes. While the garlic is roasting, boil the potatoes. When you mash (with skins on and with lumps!), squeeze out the contents of the garlic cloves into the mashing bowl. Add butter and half-and-half to get delightfully rich and creamy mashed potatoes. Serve immediately.

Orange-cranberry relish
This is something I've just recently acquired a taste for and I haven't chosen a recipe yet.

The TBD stufffing
I loathe stuffing, so Cory is choosing this recipe. TBD.

Pumpkin pie with vanilla whipped cream and V. Sattui Vintage Port
I'm a big fan of the recipe from The Joy of Cooking (1997 edition). I'll be using it with a slight modification: I bought pie pumpkins this year and I intend to use them! I'm looking forward to trying a pumpkin pie made with real, fresh ingredients. On the port: yes, I like V. Sattui. It's fantastic wine. Plus, we got married at the vineyard. Can you really blame me?

Comments

We are going to my parents' for Thanksgiving, an event which will include both my mother's and my father's extended family for the first time in years. I have volunteered to contribute two vegetable dishes which my mother reminds me not to be too disappointed about if no one eats. Ah well, at least my family's traditional thanksgiving runs to roasted turkey and simple vegetables and NO CREAM OF SOUP casseroles.

I am making: Charred Brussels Sprouts with toasted pecans (considering adding some crisp fried leeks just to really show up whatever "green bean casserole" is) and Roasted Herbed Butternut Squash. Mmmm. I am considering adding a more savory root veggie to the squash as well-- any suggestions?

Hooray for no cream of soup casseroles! My family is the same way. I hadn't even heard of green bean casserole until I was 23. Not that I was missing anything...

How did your veggie dishes go over? Did you try the shallots like I suggested?

How did it go?? :-)

I'll just say this: pumpkin pie made from fresh (not canned!) pumpkin is to die for. As for the turkey, which I had such high hopes for... well it was a bit of a tragedy. It wasn't a recipe problem, it was a my-thermometer-probe-decided-to-stop-working problem. It got a little crispy :P I was pretty heartbroken and am still kinda traumatized :) But the rest of the meal was super yummy!

How was your Thanksgiving?

Good! A little sad -- my sister is in England getting a master's degree this year and couldn't come back. The food was great, but I can already tell that Christmas will be so much better with her there!

PS -- Moved my blog to a self-hosted domain this weekend! (yay!!!)

Post a comment

(If you haven't left a comment here before, you may need to be approved by the site owner before your comment will appear. Until then, it won't appear on the entry. Thanks for waiting.)